Ankle Joint Arthritis

What Is Ankle Joint Arthritis?

Ankle joint arthritis refers to a condition characterized by the breakdown of cartilage within the ankle joint, which subsequently leads to symptoms such as pain, stiffness, and swelling. It is a common condition associated with significant morbidity and socioeconomic burden. Notably, ankle arthritis can affect both elderly individuals with comorbidities and younger adults who have a history of ankle injuries.

There are different types of ankle arthritis, with the two most prominent being osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis.

• Osteoarthritis (OA) of the ankle is primarily a result of wear-and-tear. However, unlike hip or knee OA which are often primary degenerative conditions, ankle OA is most commonly post-traumatic, developing after an injury to the ankle. Previous trauma, such as ankle fractures (especially rotational ankle fractures and tibial plafond fractures), recurrent ankle sprains, and chronic instability of the ankle joint, can disrupt the ankle cartilage and alter joint biomechanics, ultimately leading to post-traumatic arthritis. Ligamentous injuries from sports like soccer can also cause post-traumatic ankle OA, sometimes with a concomitant varus hindfoot deformity. It's important to ascertain the history of ankle injury, recurrent sprains, or previous surgical intervention when assessing ankle arthritis. While primary degenerative arthritis can occur, it is significantly less common in the ankle compared to the hip or knee due to biomechanical and anatomical factors that offer some protection to the ankle joint. These factors include the ankle's movement primarily involving rolling, whereas the knee has a combination of rolling, gliding, and rotating motions, making the knee more predisposed to primary osteoarthritis.
• Additionally, ankle cartilage, although thinner, is more uniform, stiffer, and resistant to indentation, and it does not produce the enzyme MMP8 mRNA that contributes to cartilage degradation in the knee. Ankle cartilage is also less sensitive to the effects of cytokines implicated in primary osteoarthritis. Obesity has also been identified as a risk factor for the development of OA in all three main etiology groups. The latency time between an ankle injury and the development of end-stage post-traumatic ankle OA can vary, with factors like the type of fracture, healing complications, age at injury, and hindfoot malalignment influencing this duration.
• Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) is an autoimmune disease where the body's immune system mistakenly attacks its own tissues, including the joints, causing inflammation. Foot and ankle symptoms are very common in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, with approximately 20% of patients presenting initially with these symptoms, and most patients eventually developing them. The inflammation caused by RA can lead to the destruction of articular cartilage in the ankle joint, resulting in arthritis.

The phrase "ankle bone-on-bone pain" refers to the advanced stage of ankle arthritis where the protective cartilage that normally cushions the bones within the ankle joint has significantly worn away or completely deteriorated. This loss of cartilage leads to a narrowing of the joint space. As the cartilage continues to degrade, the bones of the ankle joint (primarily the tibia and talus) can start to rub directly against each other during movement, causing significant pain.

Radiographic investigations, such as weight-bearing ankle mortise and lateral plain radiographs, can demonstrate this joint space narrowing, as well as other signs of osteoarthritis like marginal osteophytes, subchondral cysts, and sclerosis, indicating the progression towards a "bone-on-bone" state. The Takakura classification and other ankle osteoarthritis classification systems use the degree of joint space narrowing and bone contact as key indicators of the severity of the arthritis. In the later stages (e.g., Takakura Stage IV), there is obliteration of the joint space with complete bone contact. Patients with such advanced arthritis often experience pain that is worse with movement, potentially leading to discontinuation of sports, and in later stages, they may develop nocturnal inflammatory pain, stiffness, and instability. They typically seek medical help when the pain starts affecting their ability to walk or work.

Anatomy of the Arthritic Ankle

In an arthritic ankle, several anatomical changes occur that contribute to the worsening of joint function. These primarily involve cartilage erosion, the formation of bone spurs (osteophytes), and synovitis. These changes are particularly relevant to understanding ankle joint cartilage loss and tibiotalar degeneration, as the tibiotalar joint is the main articulation affected in ankle arthritis.

1. Cartilage Erosion:

• The ankle joint, like other synovial joints, relies on a layer of articular cartilage that covers the ends of the bones (tibia and talus). This cartilage provides a smooth, low-friction surface that allows for pain-free movement and absorbs shock during weight-bearing activities.
• In ankle arthritis, this cartilage undergoes progressive degradation and loss. In osteoarthritis, this can be initiated by trauma that causes irreversible cartilage damage. In rheumatoid arthritis, the autoimmune inflammatory process directly attacks and destroys the cartilage.
• As the cartilage erodes, the joint space narrows, a hallmark sign of osteoarthritis visible on radiographs. This loss of cartilage leads to increased friction between the bones. In advanced stages, the cartilage may be completely worn away, resulting in a "bone-on-bone" condition.
• The loss of the cushioning effect of cartilage and the increased friction cause pain, especially during movement and weight-bearing. Patients often describe a deep aching pain that worsens with activity. The pain can become so severe that it limits their ability to walk, work, and participate in sports.
• The incongruity resulting from cartilage loss also affects the biomechanics of the ankle joint, leading to altered loading patterns and increased mechanical forces, further contributing to the degenerative process. This tibiotalar degeneration compromises the joint's ability to move smoothly and efficiently.

2. Bone Spurs (Osteophytes):

• Osteophytes are bony outgrowths or spurs that form along the joint margins in response to cartilage damage and joint instability. They are a common feature of ankle osteoarthritis.
• The formation of these bone spurs is the body's attempt to increase the surface area of the joint and reduce stress on the damaged cartilage. However, these spurs can impinge on surrounding tissues, including ligaments and the joint capsule, further restricting the range of motion.
• For example, anterior bony spurs or osteophytes can cause pain that is worse when adopting a specific position such as the “ski-pose” or while ascending stairs, due to anterior impingement. Arthroscopic resection of these osteophytes can sometimes provide relief in early stages of arthritis with anterior impingement.
• The presence of marginal osteophytes is a key radiographic sign used in the diagnosis and classification of ankle osteoarthritis.

3. Synovitis:

• The synovium is the membrane that lines the joint capsule and produces synovial fluid, which lubricates the joint and provides nutrients to the cartilage.
• In both osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis, inflammation of the synovial membrane (synovitis) can occur. In rheumatoid arthritis, synovitis is a primary feature of the disease, driven by the autoimmune response. In osteoarthritis, synovitis can be a secondary response to cartilage breakdown and the release of inflammatory mediators.
• Synovitis leads to thickening of the synovial membrane and an increase in synovial fluid (effusion). This swelling can cause pain, stiffness, and further limit the range of motion of the ankle joint.
• In rheumatoid arthritis, the proliferative synovial tissue can invade and destroy the articular cartilage and underlying bone, contributing significantly to joint destruction and tibiotalar degeneration.
• Even in post-traumatic osteoarthritis, synovitis can exacerbate pain and stiffness, hindering normal joint mechanics.

‍

Causes and Risk Factors

Ankle arthritis can arise from various causes and has several identified risk factors, with previous trauma being the most common etiology, particularly leading to post-traumatic ankle arthritis.

1. Post-traumatic Ankle Arthritis:

• Previous Fractures: Ankle fractures, especially rotational ankle fractures and tibial plafond fractures, are significant precursors to post-traumatic ankle arthritis. A clinical study identified the incongruous reduction of intra-articular fractures as an important risk factor for its development. Even with anatomical reduction and uneventful healing of a fracture, degenerative changes can still occur in the tibiotalar joint. Studies have shown that advanced radiographic ankle OA is observed in more than one-third of patients following malleolar fractures, particularly Weber C fractures with associated medial malleolar fractures. The posterior malleolar fragment appears to be important in the development of post-traumatic OA.
• Ligament Injuries: Previous ligamental injuries are also a common cause of ankle OA. Repetitive ankle sprains in sports are a main cause of ligamentous post-traumatic ankle OA, often associated with a concomitant varus hindfoot deformity. A positive anterior drawer test and varus stress test can indicate possible injury to the anterior talofibular ligament or calcaneofibular ligament, respectively, which are potential etiologies of ankle arthritis. Even seemingly minor injuries can lead to cartilage damage that progresses to OA over time. Chronic instability of the ankle joint resulting from these injuries can also disrupt ankle cartilage and alter joint biomechanics, leading to post-traumatic arthritis. Initial cartilage damage seen arthroscopically following an ankle fracture has been identified as an independent predictor of the development of ankle OA.

2. Ankle Arthritis in Athletes:

• As mentioned above, repetitive ankle sprains, common in sports like soccer, are a significant cause of ligamentous post-traumatic ankle osteoarthritis. Athletes who experience recurrent ankle instability and ligament injuries are at a higher risk of developing ankle arthritis due to the cumulative damage to the joint cartilage and altered biomechanics. Patients may initially present with pain around the ankle joint that is worse with movements, often causing them to discontinue sports.

3. Obesity:

• Obesity has been identified as a risk factor for OA development in all three main etiology groups (post-traumatic, rheumatoid, and primary). Increased body mass index (BMI) has been linked to a higher risk of developing ankle OA after a malleolar fracture.

4. Genetics:

• Rheumatoid arthritis has a strong association with the class II major histocompatibility complex, specificity human lymphocyte antigen DR4, suggesting a genetic predisposition for this inflammatory cause of ankle arthritis. Joint dysplasias, which can have a hereditary component, can lead to secondary osteoarthritis due to abnormal joint shape and/or articular cartilage.

5. Inflammatory Conditions:

• Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) is a significant inflammatory condition that commonly affects the ankle joint. The autoimmune inflammation in RA leads to the destruction of articular cartilage and can result in ankle arthritis. Patients with RA may complain of increased pain and disability with a poor response to anti-inflammatory medication.
• Secondary osteoarthritis can also be associated with a variety of underlying diseases or disorders, such as rheumatoid disease, hemochromatosis, hemophilia, gout, neuropathic diseases, avascular talus necrosis, osteochondral lesions, and postinfectious arthritis. For instance, patients with hemophilia often present with episodes of recurrent atraumatic ankle swelling and warmth, indicative of synovial bleeds that can contribute to joint damage. Hereditary hemochromatosis is also listed as a cause of secondary osteoarthritis.

Physiotherapy’s Role in Pain Management

• Joint Mobilization: Gentle manual therapy to improve range of motion.
• Strengthening: Low-impact exercises (e.g., seated calf raises, resistance bands).
• Gait Retraining: Reduce compensatory patterns (e.g., limping).
• Modalities: Heat/ice therapy, ultrasound for pain relief.

1. Joint Mobilization:

• Gentle manual therapy techniques aimed at improving range of motion (joint mobilization) are commonly employed by physiotherapists in the management of arthritic joints. These techniques can help to address stiffness and improve joint mechanics, potentially reducing pain over time. By addressing restrictions in the ankle and surrounding joints, mobilization can contribute to a more normal gait pattern.

2. Strengthening:

• Low-impact exercises are recommended as part of non-operative management. These exercises, such as seated calf raises and exercises using resistance bands, would fall under the umbrella of strengthening. Strengthening the muscles around the ankle joint can provide better support and stability, which can help to reduce stress on the joint and alleviate pain. Stronger muscles can also improve functional abilities and reduce compensatory movement patterns.

3. Gait Retraining:

• It is important to address gait aids and shoe modifications to assist in the mechanics of a stiff or braced ankle and allow for a more normal gait. Gait retraining, which involves analyzing and correcting walking patterns, is a key aspect of physiotherapy. For patients with ankle arthritis who may have developed compensatory patterns such as limping to avoid pain, a physiotherapist can help retrain them to walk more efficiently and with less stress on the affected joint and other lower limb structures. This can contribute to pain reduction and improved function.

4. Modalities:

• Modalities are commonly used in physiotherapy practice for pain management and inflammation reduction in various musculoskeletal conditions, including arthritis.
  • Heat therapy can help to relax muscles, increase blood flow, and reduce stiffness.
  • Ice therapy can help to reduce inflammation and numb the area, providing pain relief.
  • Ultrasound is another modality that can be used to provide deep heating to tissues, potentially reducing pain and promoting healing.
  • Manual Therapy can include joint mobilization, which involves gentle manual techniques aimed at improving the range of motion of the ankle joint
  • Dry Needling can help to relief pain by targeting muscle trigger points or other soft tissue restrictions around the ankle that could be contributing to the overall pain experience

In addition to these specific techniques, physiotherapy for ankle arthritis typically involves a comprehensive assessment of the patient's condition, including pain levels, range of motion, strength, and functional limitations. Based on this assessment, a physiotherapist will develop an individualized treatment plan that may also include:

• Activity modification guidance to help patients understand which activities may exacerbate their pain and how to modify them.
• Instruction in non-weight-bearing exercises like swimming and cycling to maintain cardiovascular fitness without stressing the ankle joint.
• Education on the use of ankle braces or boots and shoe outsole modifications like a rocker sole to limit ankle joint motion and reduce pain.

Lifestyle and Activity Modifications

Lifestyle and activity modifications play a crucial role in the non-operative management of ankle arthritis, aiming to limit stress on the affected joint, manage pain, and preserve function.

1. Exercises to Avoid:

• Patients with ankle arthritis should focus on non-weight-bearing exercises such as swimming and cycling instead of impact sports. Activities that involve high impact, repetitive stress, or sudden twisting movements can exacerbate pain and potentially accelerate joint damage. Patients may initially present with pain around the ankle joint that is worse with movements, often causing them to discontinue sports.

2. Recommended Low-Impact Activities:

• To maintain cardiovascular fitness and overall well-being without putting excessive stress on the ankle joint, non-weight-bearing exercises like swimming and cycling are recommended. These activities allow for movement without the high impact associated with weight-bearing sports.

3. Orthotics for Alignment and Support:

• Patients with ankle arthritis may benefit from the use of ankle braces or boots. These can provide support, stability, and limit excessive motion of the ankle joint, which can help to reduce pain.
• Shoe outsole modifications to a rocker sole can also be beneficial, as they help in limiting ankle joint motion during walking and can assist in forward propulsion, leading to a more normal gait. Additionally, orthotic appliances are mentioned as part of non-operative treatment, likely aimed at providing support and improving alignment.

4. Weight Management for Joint Health:

• Limiting weight-bearing forces through the ankle joint is a key strategy in managing ankle arthritis. Weight reduction, if needed, is therefore an important lifestyle modification. Obesity has been identified as a risk factor for OA development, and increased body mass index (BMI) has been linked to a higher risk of developing ankle OA after a malleolar fracture. Reducing excess weight can decrease the load on the ankle joint, potentially alleviating pain and slowing the progression of arthritis.

Prognosis and Long-Term Care

The management of ankle arthritis focuses on slowing its progression and alleviating symptoms, as the underlying condition is typically degenerative. While a complete reversal of ankle arthritis is generally not anticipated, patients can experience significant improvements in pain and function with appropriate management.

Can Ankle Arthritis Improve?

• Non-operative treatments like lifestyle and activity modifications, physiotherapy, analgesics, and anti-inflammatory medications aim to provide symptom relief and slow the progression of the disease. Patients may experience periods of reduced pain and improved mobility with these strategies.
• Joint-preserving surgical interventions such as arthroscopic debridement, periarticular osteotomy, and distraction arthroplasty may offer benefits in carefully selected patients with early arthritis, potentially deferring the need for more definitive procedures. For instance, arthroscopic debridement can be effective for anterior impingement pain in early arthritis. Realignment osteotomies can help in cases of focal arthritis due to malalignment. Distraction arthroplasty aims to allow cartilage repair in younger patients with good residual motion.
• For end-stage arthritis, surgical options like ankle arthrodesis (fusion) and total ankle replacement (TAR) aim to relieve pain and improve function, although they do not "improve" the arthritic condition in the sense of restoring the joint to its original state.

Ankle Fusion vs Replacement:

• Ankle Arthrodesis: This is considered the gold standard surgical treatment for advanced ankle arthritis, especially in patients with a painful, stiff, deformed, or unstable ankle where loss of motion is unlikely to significantly compromise overall function. It aims to eliminate pain, correct deformity, and create a stable foot. Fusion rates are generally high. However, it results in a stiff ankle joint and alters gait patterns. There is also a potential for progression of arthritis in adjacent joints over the long term.
• Total Ankle Replacement: This aims to retain ankle motion, which is its main advantage over fusion. It can lead to improved gait velocity, stride length, and cadence compared to ankle fusion. However, complication rates and re-operation rates have been reported to be higher with TAR compared to ankle fusion. TAR is often offered to older patients with lower physical demands and less severe deformity. Implant survival rates are acceptable, but aseptic loosening is a potential long-term complication requiring surveillance.

Timeline for Relief and Lifelong Management:

• The duration for which non-operative treatment is pursued can vary depending on the individual's symptoms and response. 6-12 weeks for symptom relief is the general timeframe often associated with initial trials of conservative treatments like physiotherapy and medication.
• Ankle arthritis can be a chronic condition requiring lifelong management. Even after surgical intervention, ongoing care, including follow-up and potential management of complications or adjacent joint issues, may be necessary.

FAQs About Ankle Arthritis

• Can physiotherapy delay surgery?Yes, physiotherapy can potentially delay the need for surgery in ankle arthritis. The sources indicate that a trial of physiotherapy should be offered as part of non-operative management before considering surgical intervention. Furthermore, non-surgical treatment, which includes physiotherapy, aims to preserve mobility and function, thus potentially averting or at least delaying ankle surgery.
• What shoes are best for arthritic ankles?For arthritic ankles, modifications to footwear can be beneficial. Patients may find relief using shoe outsole modifications to a rocker sole, which helps limit ankle joint motion. Additionally, rocker-bottom and cushioned soles can assist in the mechanics of a stiff or braced ankle, allowing for enhanced forward propulsion and a more normal gait.

Ready to Overcome Ankle Arthritis?

Our Specialized Approach to Rehab

Our comprehensive treatment programs include:

• Detailed biomechanical assessment of your ankle and lower limb
• Customized exercise programs to improve strength, flexibility, and joint stability
• Advanced manual therapy techniques to reduce pain and inflammation
• Progressive loading protocols tailored to your activity level and goals
• Regular monitoring and program adjustments to ensure optimal recovery

Why Choose Our Clinic for Ankle Arthritis Treatment?

1. Evidence-Based Expertise
   • Treatment protocols based on the latest research in arthritis management
   • Specialized training in joint rehabilitation and pain relief
   • Proven track record with both athletic and non-athletic populations
2. Personalized Care
   • Individual assessment of your ankle condition and overall health
   • Custom treatment plans designed to address your specific needs
   • Regular progress tracking and program modifications to ensure success
3. Comprehensive Recovery Support
   • Education on managing daily activities to reduce joint stress
   • Guidance on safe return to sport, exercise, or daily routines
   • Long-term strategies to prevent further joint damage and maintain mobility

Take the First Step Toward Recovery

Don’t let ankle arthritis limit your mobility or affect your quality of life. Our experienced team is ready to help you build a strong foundation for lasting recovery.

Book Your Specialized Assessment Today:

• Phone: 905-669-1221
• Location: 398 Steeles Ave W #201, Thornhill, ON L4J 6X3
• Online Booking: www.vaughanphysiotherapy.com

Serving communities across Thornhill, Langstaff, Newtonbrook, Willowdale, North York, Markham, Richmond Hill, Concord, and North Toronto.

Conveniently located in the heart of Thornhill, offering flexible scheduling to accommodate your recovery needs.

Your Path to Recovery Starts Here

Whether you're dealing with recent onset pain or a chronic condition, our proven approach to rehabilitation can help you return to the activities you love. Contact us today to begin your journey back to pain-free movement.

‍